Test Your Understanding of Modifier 57



Become a modifier expert by looking at the numbers.

Pop quiz: A patient is admitted to the hospital. The provider orders a workup on the first day and, based on the results, makes the decision to perform a partial colectomy, which is performed the following day. In addition to reporting 44140 Colectomy, partial; with anastomosis, you want to code for the initial hospital evaluation and management (E/M) with 99222 Initial hospital care, per day, for the evaluation and management of a patient ….

In this scenario, can you bill for both the E/M and the procedure? If you can, does the E/M code require a modifier? And if it does, which modifier do you use?

2 Modifiers, 1 Major Decision

Whenever a provider sees a patient and the E/M service reveals a condition that requires a procedure, you can claim for both the E/M and the procedure, providing you follow the guidelines detailed below. However, you will need to add the correct modifier to the E/M to get paid for both the E/M and the procedure.

The two modifiers generally used in this kind of scenario are modifier 25 Significant, separately identifiable evaluation and management service by the same physician or other qualified healthcare professional on the same day of the procedure or other service and modifier 57 Decision for surgery.

In our scenario, you may be tempted to eliminate modifier 25 simply on the basis of the words “the same day” in the modifier descriptor since the provider performed the colectomy the day after the E/M. The decision not to use modifier 25 in this scenario is correct, but for a different reason, which you shall see shortly.

You may also be tempted to think this means there is no need to apply a modifier at all. But here’s why that would be incorrect.

90 Plus 2 Equals …

Even though the provider performed the colectomy the day after the E/M, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) regards the E/M as being performed during the global surgical package for 44140. The package, “also called global surgery, includes all the necessary services normally furnished by a surgeon before, during, and after a procedure,” according to CMS.

CPT® 44140 is assigned a 90-day global package, which CMS defines as “1 day before the surgery, the day of the surgery and 90 days following the surgery, totaling 92 days.” In other words, the E/M occurred during the 90-day global package for 44140, so a modifier is necessary.

And 92 Will Get You 57

The global package assigned to a procedure also determines the appropriate modifier choice to unbundle an E/M service from a same-day procedure. CMS assigns three different kinds of global period to procedures, depending on whether they are major (90 days) or minor (10 days or 0 days).

As we have seen, by assigning 44140 a 90-day global period, CMS has determined that a colectomy is a major procedure. This means you can bill the “initial consultation or evaluation of the problem by the surgeon to determine the need for major surgeries … separately using the modifier ‘-57,’” as the visit “may be billed separately only for major surgical procedures,” according to CMS.

For minor procedures, however, “the initial evaluation for minor surgical procedures and endoscopies is always included in the global surgery package,” per CMS guidelines. Even so, you can use modifier 25 to unbundle an E/M from the procedure, providing the E/M is “a significant, separately identifiable service … performed … by the same physician on the same day of the procedure,” CMS guidelines go on to say.

It All Adds Up to This

In the end, you would code the initial scenario as 44140, 99222-57. So, if this was your answer to our pop quiz, go to the head of the class — you have just mastered modifier 57 math!

Evaluation and Management – CEMC

Latest posts by Bruce Pegg (see all)
Translate »